• Problems Related to the Use of the Category of Magic in the Writing of Greek and Roman History

    Olivier Dufault (see profile)
    Religious Studies
    Religion, Magic, Methodology, Religions, Civilization, Greco-Roman, History, Religion--Social aspects
    Item Type:
    Pierre Bourdieu, Etic/emic, Theology of Religions, Greco-Roman religion, Sociology of religion
    Permanent URL:
    This paper was originally prepared for a meeting of the Methodology Seminar of the Distant Worlds Graduate School (LMU, Munich) and was meant as an introduction to the use of the category of magic in the study of ancient Greek and Roman religions offered to a group of scholars coming from different disciplines. The study of ancient magic is complicated by the fact that most of ancient Greek and Latin terms usually translated by “magic” or “magical” were used in different and contradictory ways. Approaches trying to reconcile rather than expose these different meanings can be divided in two large groups: the so-called essentialist approach, exemplified here by the work of H.S. Versnel and the sociological approach, represented here by the work of P. Bourdieu. Against these two approaches, it has also been argued that the modern term “magic” should be abandoned. Against this last position, I will first repeat – as Versnel and others already did – that we cannot represent alien (i.e. foreign or ancient) categories of thought without using our own categories. Finally, I will present Versnel’s methodology, its problems, and the solution that Bourdieu’s notion of the religious field can provide. While not without problems, it gives an idea of what could be gained by tinkering with common-sense notions rather than assuming that their definitions are self-evident.
    Published as:
    Journal article    
    Last Updated:
    4 years ago
    All Rights Reserved


    Item Name: pdf problems-related-to-the-use-of-the-category-of-magic-in-the-writing-of-greek-and-roman-history.pdf
      Download View in browser
    Activity: Downloads: 95